PDA

View Full Version : electrons and 'work'- what happens


orange31
10th December 2008, 11:23 AM
Simplistic question, I understand how electrons come from power source, thru a motor/any device, return via ground to source. Same number of electrons start to finish.
My question is, what is the change in the electrons that reflects the energy consumed to perform the work?

drkitten
10th December 2008, 11:34 AM
Simplistic question, I understand how electrons come from power source, thru a motor/any device, return via ground to source. Same number of electrons start to finish.
My question is, what is the change in the electrons that reflects the energy consumed to perform the work?

Reduced voltage (or electromotive force).

Ziggurat
10th December 2008, 11:45 AM
drikitten's response is correct, but it may not be quite what you're looking for. One way to get a bit of a more "physical" picture of what's going on is to consider electrons in a metal kind of like a gas with a pressure. Electrons repel each other, so the more electrons you shove into a metal, the higher the "pressure" (corresponding to more negative voltage). Electrons will try to flow away from the higher pressure to lower pressure, just like a gas would, and they can do work (like heating the filiment in a lightbulb) in the process.

This is an imperfect analogy for a number of reasons (in other words, don't look for perfect correspondance), one of which is that the electron density at any one spot isn't the only thing that affects voltage at that spot (in a chunk of metal without any current, the voltage is equal everywhere but any net electron charge will be on the surface only). Another difference is that it's a FANTASTICALLY stiff "gas": the fractional change in electron density needed to make HUGE changes to the voltage are very small. But voltage differences (and the corresponding electric fields) are created by increasing or decreasing the electron density in your conductor, even if by only very tiny amounts. In contrast, ordinary gasses need significant density changes in order to experience significant pressure changes (assuming fixed temperature, of course).

Madalch
10th December 2008, 12:00 PM
It's similar to a water wheel. Water flows downstream, turns the wheel and does useful work. What is the change in the water that reflects the work it's done?

Gord_in_Toronto
10th December 2008, 12:16 PM
It's similar to a water wheel. Water flows downstream, turns the wheel and does useful work. What is the change in the water that reflects the work it's done?

Lower Potential Energy? ;)

drkitten
10th December 2008, 12:35 PM
drikitten's response is correct, but it may not be quite what you're looking for. One way to get a bit of a more "physical" picture of what's going on is to consider electrons in a metal kind of like a gas with a pressure. Electrons repel each other, so the more electrons you shove into a metal, the higher the "pressure" (corresponding to more negative voltage). Electrons will try to flow away from the higher pressure to lower pressure, just like a gas would, and they can do work (like heating the filiment in a lightbulb) in the process.

Thanks. I was trying to find a physical analogy to use but failing to find a way to express it that wasn't "obviously wrong"[tm].

Madalch
10th December 2008, 01:03 PM
Lower Potential Energy?
Yep- just like the electrons.

If you have a battery that operates by the flow of electrons from zinc to copper ion, the electrons have a lower potential energy in the orbitals around copper than they do when they're in the orbitals of a zinc atom.

Soapy Sam
10th December 2008, 04:07 PM
It's like when you use your credit card to pay a bill.
Credit card does work, gets hot, remaining credit is reduced, spending power goes down.

Hey- it's a metaphor for the "Me Generation"

orange31
10th December 2008, 07:55 PM
If you have a battery that operates by the flow of electrons from zinc to copper ion, the electrons have a lower potential energy in the orbitals around copper than they do when they're in the orbitals of a zinc atom.

Aha! thanks!

wackyvorlon
10th December 2008, 08:17 PM
Around the turn of the century, it was common to use water as an analogy. One paper by Tesla even refers to currents of "high pressure", which we would today consider voltage. Vacuum tubes in the UK are still referred to as valves.