PDA

View Full Version : Credulity and conspiracy


sackett
7th November 2003, 11:26 AM
A chronic practice among believers of various stripes is to find a conspiratorial explanation for the lack of data to support their views. I've seen this mentality put in proposition form:

1. I believe in UFOs.
2. Therefore, evidence for UFOs must exist.
3. But this evidence is never forthcoming; therefore
5. SOMEBODY'S COVERING UP!

Or, in the simpler terms used by simpler folk: Them there science fellers is finding out that the Bible stories is true, but oh! they are a keeping it quiet.

Because of the nature of my work in a couple of universities, I've spent my adult life among scientists. I've noticed that in the main they're an open-minded lot, willing to test just about anything - including stuff I wouldn't spend much time on, but then I've examined more woo-hoo claims than they have, and I'm jaded.

Knowing what I do about them science fellers, I can say this: If one or several of them uncovered evidence for something extraordinary, something we call supernatural, there'd be a mighty much of shoving and elbowing to see who could publish first.

Nyarlathotep
7th November 2003, 11:57 AM
The popularity of crying 'cover-up' when no evidence of the paranormal is forthcoming springs, I think, from the fact that it is a ver convenient post-hoc hypothesis that can be applied to nearly any situation.

I am not a scientist either, but my observation has been that the surest way for a scientist to make a name for himself is to blow away some old established theory, provided he has sufficient evidence to back up his case and isn't just blowing smoke. Thus, if scientists had the sort of evidence these people claim that they do, most scientists wouldn't cover it up, they would fall all over themselves to publish it, thinking "Nobel Prize, here I come!" all the while.

Ratman_tf
7th November 2003, 11:59 AM
How do we know you're not part of the conspiracy?!?!? :wink8:

sackett
7th November 2003, 12:28 PM
Originally posted by Ratman_tf
How do we know you're not part of the conspiracy?!?!? :wink8:

Why do you ask? Who are you working for?

Anyway, that was not me who posted. It was some imposter. I know nothing, nothing.