PDA

View Full Version : A passage for Bill Hoyt


Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
20th November 2003, 08:29 PM
Awhile ago, Bill made this statement, which I am still using as my email sig line:
Concerning dualism: Why should I be concerned with your impotent, girlie-ghost? It seems to me that, if it exists at all, my chemicals are far more powerful. My surgery trumps the phantasm every time. Why should I care that you can construct such a lame ideation? I can put it to sleep by turning the gas knob.
I just finished reading Rita Carter's Mapping the Mind, which ends with this paragraph:
The findings outlined in this book give only the sketchiest impression of the landscape of the mind---the task of creating a detailed picture is one for the new millennium and beyond. Yet I believe one thing is already clear: there is no ghost in this place, no monsters in the depths, no lands ruled by dragons. What today's mind voyagers are discovering is instead a biological system of awe-inspiring complexity. There is no need for us to satisfy our sense of wonder by conjuring phantoms---the world within our heads is more marvellous than anything we can dream up.


~~ Paul

!Xx+-Rational-+xX!
20th November 2003, 10:54 PM
I swear I will start posting here when drunk!

Yahweh
21st November 2003, 01:41 AM
the world within our heads is more marvellous than anything we can dream up.

No one ever said reality was unremarkable...

BillHoyt
21st November 2003, 11:28 AM
Originally posted by Yahweh


No one ever said reality was unremarkable...

Weyellll, they get close to it, however, when they make dualist assertions. The argument is usually a thinly-disguised argument from ignorance: "Science doesn't yet understand consciousness, therefore I assert there be ghosts in those machines." In that sense, they are saying reality is unremarkable and that they must substitute this fantasy to explain mind.

BillHoyt
21st November 2003, 11:33 AM
Paul,

Its a good passage, btw. Thanks for calling my attention to it.