PDA

View Full Version : The History Channel's "That's Impossible"


The Nimble Pianist
12th August 2009, 08:51 PM
A couple weeks ago I set my DVR to record episodes of this new series on the History Channel called "That's Impossible" (http://www.history.com/video.do?name=Thats_Impossible). The ads for the series mentioned that the object was to discuss the new technology of today which can serve as precursors to the technology of tomorrow which in turn may prove to be the culmination of that which science fiction writers could only hope. The series looked promising and so I set for it to record.

The first episode I watched seemed alright. It was titled "Eternal Life". It was mostly science based, and paid most attention to what's cutting edge today with only a quick introduction to Dr. Aubrey de Grey's at worst naive belief (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aubrey_de_Grey)that living past the age of 1000 could be a reality for those living even today. Considering the source, I was pleasantly surprised in the lack of pseudoscience and conspiracy theory in this episode.

Then I moved on to the episodes about weather manipulation, and mind control. The former spent almost a half hour of the hour slot making blind appeals to "many people" and their beliefs about the USSR and China using chem-trails to cause the 89 earthquake in California as well as the drought in the early 90's. The latter spent about equal time discussing the "targeted individuals" who insist that the US Government has been reading their minds for the sake of some unspecified function of the military.

With each episode I'm beginning to notice the focus shift more and more to two things:

- Possible wartime scenarios for which these hypothetical technologies might be employed,

- The tin-foil-hatters whose "experiences" allegedly demonstrate that these technologies are not so hypothetical.


Not only am I disappointed that this show for which I was initially so hopeful has shown itself to be a bust, I fear that damned channel is finding more novel, and most importantly subtle ways of introducing woo into everything they present.

What better way to pass off fringe conspiracy theory as plausible than juxtaposing it with scientists discussing technology they've actually created which is only peripherally related to the conspiracy theory in the first place?

The Nimble Pianist
12th August 2009, 09:05 PM
Would a mod be so kind as to move this to "Conspiracy Theories".

I haven't the slightest clue why I posted it here. :o

tyr_13
12th August 2009, 09:24 PM
Yeah, it saddens me that Captain Riker has fallen so far.

Policenaut
12th August 2009, 10:39 PM
I think I remember seeing one of their regular commentators on some discovery channel show saying that the US and British governments are keeping UFO secrets from the world. Obviously this guy is someone you want to consult regarding science related issues.

Perspective
13th August 2009, 04:28 AM
I've seen the one on mindcontrol as well, it was very disappointing. It's sad the the "history" channel is moving in this direction.

alfaniner
13th August 2009, 06:12 AM
Yeah, it saddens me that Captain Riker has fallen so far.

Are you kidding? He narrated "Alien Autopsy" several years ago.

tyr_13
13th August 2009, 08:39 AM
Are you kidding? He narrated "Alien Autopsy" several years ago.

Yeah, but he also did the Fox specials "UFOs: Best Evidence Caught on Tape", and "Ghosts: Best Evidence Yet," and they both were fairly critical of the 'evidence'. It was the first time I saw the Phoenix Lights, and the first time I saw them debunked.

tyr_13
13th August 2009, 08:40 AM
Back on the show, I saw the weather one, and they even had that idiot who self-published, 'Angles Don't Play this HARP' as some kind of expert. It was terrible.

Comrade Raptor
13th August 2009, 09:08 AM
I've seen the one on mindcontrol as well, it was very disappointing. It's sad the the "history" channel is moving in this direction.

"Moving"?

Ice Road Truckers, lumberjacks, UFOs, monsters, ghosts, hitler and the occult...

This channel isn't "moving" into the land of Woo, it set up permanent residence some time ago.

So far as I can tell, the last gasp of anything remotely historical was Dogfights.

dudalb
13th August 2009, 02:34 PM
TO be fair, I rather like "Ice Road Truckers" but agree it should be on Discovery or A and E not The History Channel.

Comrade Raptor
13th August 2009, 04:08 PM
I liked it too, but as you say it really had little business being on the History Channel.

We've got 6,000 years of recorded human history (some of it very strange indeed) plus what we've been able to construct and theorize from before then. I should think that would provide plenty of actual historical fodder without resorting to the junk HC puts on (or their previous war channel fetish).

The people at that network must be exceptionally lazy, even for TV people.

JoeyDonuts
13th August 2009, 11:31 PM
What happened to Battle 360? Cities of the Underground? Would it kill them to actually talk to some history professors?!?

What the hell is going on over there?

Meh. I switched to NATGEO a while back.

Blender Head
14th August 2009, 12:15 AM
"Moving"?

Ice Road Truckers, lumberjacks

How are these two indicative of HC's "Woo" programming? I don't watch either, but I don't understand why they're included with UFOs and monsters.

Comrade Raptor
14th August 2009, 03:03 AM
Yeah, I should have separated the two. My global point was programming inappropriate for the channel, then specifically the woo side of things, but I didn't adequately separate the two in my post.

Since lumberjacks and ice road truckers is more the Reality TV side of things.

alfaniner
14th August 2009, 04:31 AM
Well, I'm sure there's a lot more of that type of show to be mined. Regardless of which network they're on, we already have Ice Road Truckers, Ax Men, Swamp Loggers, Ice Loggers, Ax Truckers, Log Axers, Truck Swampers, you get the idea... Each with a disparate and dysfunctional crew. Now it's morphing to ocean fishing shows.

dudalb
14th August 2009, 10:10 AM
Well, I'm sure there's a lot more of that type of show to be mined. Regardless of which network they're on, we already have Ice Road Truckers, Ax Men, Swamp Loggers, Ice Loggers, Ax Truckers, Log Axers, Truck Swampers, you get the idea... Each with a disparate and dysfunctional crew. Now it's morphing to ocean fishing shows.

Just like most offices and workplaces.At least everyone I have worked at, and I don't think I am very unusual.

technoextreme
14th August 2009, 07:31 PM
Well, I'm sure there's a lot more of that type of show to be mined. Regardless of which network they're on, we already have Ice Road Truckers, Ax Men, Swamp Loggers, Ice Loggers, Ax Truckers, Log Axers, Truck Swampers, you get the idea... Each with a disparate and dysfunctional crew. Now it's morphing to ocean fishing shows.
What in gods hell given name are you talking about? It started with the freaking ocean fishing shows and then progressed from their. GIVE ME YOUR NERD BADGE. GIVE IT TO ME. And you know what the disturbing fact is. They are all made by the same company.