PDA

View Full Version : Cloned animals are safe to eat, says report


jay gw
12th April 2005, 03:53 PM
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Meat and milk from cloned cattle are virtually identical to the same products from prize animals bred the old-fashioned way, researchers in Japan and the United States reported on Tuesday.

While cautioning that their study is not the definitive report on whether it is safe to eat cloned animals, the researchers said it suggested they might be.

Xiangzhong Yang of the University of Connecticut and colleagues at the National Institute of Agrobiological Science and National Institute of Animal Health in Kagoshima, Japan, cloned beef and dairy cattle and examined their meat and milk.

They compared the meat and milk from the clones to that of animals of similar age, breed and genetics bred naturally.

"We found no significant differences in the composition of milk from cloned animals compared with the comparator animals managed under the same conditions," the researchers wrote in their report, to be published this week in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

The differences found in meat related to levels of fat and fatty acids and muscle qualities.

Their analysis also suggested that the clones were healthy and normal based on examination of their chromosomes, which carry the genes, as well as development and behavior.

In 2002 a National Academy of Sciences panel said it appeared that products from cloned animals were safe to eat but noted there had been very few studies. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration is expected to issue its initial guidance on the safety of cloned animals products soon.

http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml?type=topNews&storyID=8157055&src=rss/topNews

Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
12th April 2005, 05:45 PM
So what's the question? Whether it's safe to eat cloned animals or whether it's silly to worry about it?

~~ Paul

anonimouse
12th April 2005, 05:52 PM
As long as it grills well, I really don't care if the cow is cloned.

Rob Lister
12th April 2005, 06:16 PM
Originally posted by sodakboy93
As long as it grills well, I really don't care if the cow is cloned.

Oh, I disagree wholeheartedly. I'd much perfer to eat the cloned animal because then I'd be better assured as to what I was getting. They are not going to clone the dregs of the herd, they're going to clone the cream. Perfectly marbled, tender, meaty, no grissle to speak of. It might be the best steak you ever ate.

Dilb
12th April 2005, 10:51 PM
I probably won't, simply because it would probably be way more expensive. If cloning somehow offers me a chance to eat Wagyu steak for $5/lb, I'd eat it as often as possible.

crimresearch
12th April 2005, 11:08 PM
OK, the first time I saw this story, it said that cloned meat was 'almost the same' in taste as the real thing.
Then they changed it to say 'as safe as '...

I'm waiting for the other hoof to drop.

Drooper
13th April 2005, 02:30 AM
Safe to eat, or tastes the same?

Either way the the obvious response seems D'uuuhh.

Rolfe
13th April 2005, 06:03 AM
As far as safety goes, I simply can't imagine any way that cloned meat would be unsafe. Given the way the digestive process works, we can eat protein from a very wide variety of sources and treat it all the same. I wouldn't have a problem eating meat from a severely deformed cloned animal, from a safety point of view.

As far as taste goes, who knows? So far as I'm aware they never served up roast Dolly, and if there have been any palatability tests on any other cloned individuals I haven't seen the results.

Rolfe.

Jorghnassen
13th April 2005, 07:20 AM
But cloned meat is going to miss the tastiest part of the animal: the soul!

/stolen from a farker's comment.

anonimouse
13th April 2005, 09:06 AM
Originally posted by Rob Lister
Oh, I disagree wholeheartedly. I'd much perfer to eat the cloned animal because then I'd be better assured as to what I was getting. They are not going to clone the dregs of the herd, they're going to clone the cream. Perfectly marbled, tender, meaty, no grissle to speak of. It might be the best steak you ever ate.

I live in South Dakota. Cow is cow, as long as you don't go with the sick mangy one. It's all in the grilling and prep, IMO.