PDA

View Full Version : Are Dogs Superstitious?


Jeff Corey
6th July 2005, 08:34 PM
B. F. Skinner defined "superstitious" behavior as behavior under the control of noncontingent reinforcement, or reinforcement occurring without any causal connection with the organism's behavior. ("Superstition in the Pigeon", 1948)
In humans, we call it "Post hoc, ergo propter hoc."
We are familiar with human superstitions such as "lucky" clothes, rituals such as rain dances and Episcopalianism.
But what about my dog Molly? For the past three days, she has been barking whenever fireworks are detonated and keeps barking until they stop.
Is this like the legendary Hekawi tribe that danced until it rained?

CaveDave
7th July 2005, 01:41 AM
I'd say so from watching dogs "circle" before laying down.

Dave

Darat
7th July 2005, 01:46 AM
So her barks make the fireworks stop -smart dog.

LostAngeles
7th July 2005, 02:46 AM
Or it might be that she presumes that the "danger" (fireworks) has been scared away by her barking?

hgc
7th July 2005, 06:26 AM
Originally posted by Jeff Corey
...
Is this like the legendary Hekawi tribe that danced until it rained? We're the Hekawi!

:dl:

Oh, that's rich. Agarn!!!!

edited to add: Above laughing dog not supersititious in the least, but a straight-up nihilist.