PDA

View Full Version : War reporting accuracy - a funnier example


iain
15th April 2003, 05:38 AM
A BBC article (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/2948747.stm) reports how a story which spread around the world about a British Marine having a "miracle escape" after being shot in the head (his helmet stopping the bullets) turns out to be untrue.

What I find interesting about this is that the story would have been easy for any motivated journalist to verify : just ask the guy. It seems that no one bothered - maybe it suited them to jump to conclusions. Doubtless many "experts" were pulled in to give their opinions on how this guy survived.

Three weeks ago it was reported that commando Eric Walderman escaped death by an inch after four bullets lodged in his helmet when he was fired on by Iraqi forces in the port of Umm Qsar.

But it has emerged the holes in the helmet were caused by Mr Walderman's fellow marines, part of the 40 Commando's Alpha Company, based at Taunton, Somerset.

They hit the helmet which was lying on top of a pack as they tried to detonate an unexploded anti-tank weapon.

Jon_in_london
15th April 2003, 05:52 AM
Oh thanks! Now I dont have any confidence in those helmets anymore :rolleyes:

iain
15th April 2003, 05:54 AM
Originally posted by Jon_in_london
Oh thanks! Now I dont have any confidence in those helmets anymore :rolleyes: Let me guess - you've been walking around London wearing one for the last two weeks and you felt safe. Now you feel vulnerable again. :D

Jon_in_london
15th April 2003, 05:59 AM
Originally posted by iain
Let me guess - you've been walking around London wearing one for the last two weeks and you felt safe. Now you feel vulnerable again. :D

Yes, it get a bit hot in the tube but.......
I guess next you will be telling me the gas-mask I wear to work every morning is past its sell-by date ;)

No really, Im TA.

Reginald
15th April 2003, 06:21 AM
Jon,


If it is a gas mask of the type that comes in a box with the words "Property of the third Reich" I would be checking to see if the rubber is perishing. Otherwise you should be Ok.

As for the story, its one of those "Chirpy, cheeky, Brit laughs off death" type of things. Totally devoid of any facts. I didnt look to see if he was a cockney. That adds a further dimension and indeed another word beginning with the letter "C".

:D