PDA

View Full Version : Media bias? The BBC vs. No. 10 Downing Street


BillyTK
27th June 2003, 03:20 AM
The BBC has got into a bit of a tiff with Prime Minister Tony Blair's "Director of Communications" Alistair Campbell, over a report by BBC journalist Andrew Gilligan which mentioned that:
[...]a senior British intelligence official had told him that the government's first dossier on Iraq's weapons programme, published last September, had been "sexed up" at Downing Street's request.

In particular, the official claimed that Downing Street had asked for extra prominence to be given to the suggestion Iraq could launch a chemical or biological strike within 45 minutes of an order.

Mr Campbell--who is an influential, but unelected member of Blair's inner circle--claims that the BBC is pursuing an anti-war agenda. However, Labour MP Brian Donohoe has suggested that this is a deliberate tactic to divert attention from the buck-passing heard at the Commons foreign affairs select committee, which is currently investigating the evidence used to justify the Britain's involvement in the war on Iraq.

Straw says, "Them bigger boys made us do it!" (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/3015272.stm)
Campbell says, "That BBC is a bloody bunch of commies!" (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/3020448.stm)
The BBC says, "Put up or shut up, Campbell!" (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/3021626.stm)

Poor BBC, they're often criticised for being too establishment and right-wing, and now they're being criticised for being too anti-establishment! And by an employee of a Labour Prime Minister, no less!

LillyThePink
27th June 2003, 03:21 AM
I was actually quite pleased that the BBC seemed to be having a bit of a pop instead of propogating the spin... till I started wondering what "news" we are being diverted from...

me? paranoid?? ho hum.

BillyTK
27th June 2003, 04:21 AM
Originally posted by LillyThePink
I was actually quite pleased that the BBC seemed to be having a bit of a pop instead of propogating the spin... till I started wondering what "news" we are being diverted from...

me? paranoid?? ho hum.

A few reasons for the diversion:
1. Draw attention from Jack Straw dobbing Alistair Campbell in;
2. More indepth coverage of Iraq in the light of the deaths of the six military police officers.
3. The new extradition treaty I mentioned here (http://host.randi.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?s=&threadid=22193) is about to go to Parliament.

Finer scales, Lily, finer scales. ;)

reprise
27th June 2003, 04:30 AM
The Beeb's in good company. Our ABC was recently under fire from our Communications Minister for having an "anti-American bias". What a shame that the station call logs showed that the majority of callers who complained about the ABC's reporting of the Iraq conflict perceived the coverage as being pro-US.

Surely one of the functions of a public broadcaster should be to put government policy under the microscope, and surely in a democracy it should be able to do so without threats of funding being cut (which is what happened here).

andycal
27th June 2003, 04:46 AM
Alistair Campbell is a liability to the government, but as I'm growing weary of Tony and his cronies, I say leave him in, he's the best weapon the opposition have got...

BillyTK
27th June 2003, 05:25 AM
Originally posted by reprise
Surely one of the functions of a public broadcaster should be to put government policy under the microscope, and surely in a democracy it should be able to do so without threats of funding being cut (which is what happened here).

Aye, there's the rub; "Aunty Beeb" is normally seen as too supportive and uncritical of government!

BillyTK
27th June 2003, 05:26 AM
Originally posted by andycal
Alistair Campbell is a liability to the government, but as I'm growing weary of Tony and his cronies, I say leave him in, he's the best weapon the opposition have got...

...and don't the opposition need it! ;)